Sellers Are Pricing Off the Wrong Number

Sellers Are Pricing Off the Wrong Number: The Rainey Report Austin hero photo

The Rainey Report by Troy Knight and Andrea Corrales

Five generations of Austin. Seven generations of Texas. The Rainey Report is how Troy Knight and Andrea Corrales share what we know: honest market data and what’s getting built near you, delivered straight.

From the September 16, 2026 edition. Get the next one in your inbox.

Keys to the Market

The Number Nobody’s Pricing Their House Off Of

There’s a 15-point gap hiding in Austin’s own housing data, and almost every seller is on the wrong side of it.

Two sellers can list the same kind of house this month and be arguing from two completely different sets of facts. Only one of them is right.

There’s a number floating around every listing appointment in Austin right now: the market’s off maybe ten percent from the peak. It’s the kind of thing that sounds true because it’s close to true, and it’s exactly the kind of half-true number that gets a house priced wrong for ninety days before somebody finally drops it.

Here’s the real one – I ran the August numbers this month, and the gap between what sellers think happened and what actually happened is embarrassing. Average list price, the flattering number, is down 11.4% from the 2023 peak. Median sold price per square foot, the number that doesn’t care how big your house is or what you wish it was worth, is down 26.4%. Same market. Same month. Same MLS. One of those numbers is lying to you by omission, and it’s not the smaller one.

The trick is averages get seduced by whatever happens to sell that month. Pricier homes moved the average up while the typical house kept sliding, which is a fancy way of saying the rich houses are doing the average’s PR. Strip that out and look at dollars per square foot instead, and Austin’s median has gone from $280 to $206 since April 2022. That’s not a correction anymore. That’s a full-on hangover, and it’s been four years, and the aspirin still hasn’t kicked in.

Even downtown, which likes to act like it’s above all this, isn’t actually above it, it just moved its own peak later so the math looks better. City average list price technically peaked in September 2025, which sounds encouraging until you realize that’s not a pandemic high; that’s just pricier new listings showing up recently and dragging the average around by the collar. Control for square footage and downtown’s decline lands right on top of the suburbs’: 26 percent, give or take. Everybody’s in the same boat. Some of them just have nicer paint on the hull.

And just when you’d think the bleeding stopped, August decided to reopen it. A year ago the market was down two-tenths of a percent, basically flat, and everybody exhaled. This August: down 3.6% year over year. Turns out the floor wasn’t a floor. It was a landing on the way to the actual floor, which nobody’s found yet.

Our Take

Every seller has a favorite number, and it’s almost never the one that actually describes their house. It’s the average, not the median. The list price, not what closed. Pricing off that number doesn’t just risk a slower sale; it guarantees a string of price cuts that ultimately teach the market the same lesson the per-square-foot data already knew. Ask your agent which number they used to set your price. If the answer is anything other than price per square foot in your specific pocket of the city, ask again.

Shaping Austin

The 3M Plant Nobody Asked to Become a Data Center

A shuttered Northwest Austin factory is turning into a 50-megawatt data campus, and the city has no rulebook to say otherwise.

Nobody in River Place or Four Points got a vote on this. By the time anyone noticed, the permits were already signed.

The former 3M plant at 6801 River Place Blvd sat empty long enough that most of Northwest Austin stopped thinking about it. Now it’s becoming the Cosmos Technology Campus, a million square feet that a securities filing from parent company SB Energy says will run up to 50 megawatts of data center capacity at peak use. That’s enough electricity to power roughly 40,000 households, except none of those households get to live there. They just get to share the grid with it.

Here’s the part that’ll get you: the site’s still zoned for research and development, not data centers, and there’s currently nothing in city code that requires anybody to check which one you’re actually building. SB Energy’s own SEC filing says the space is leased “primarily for data centers and office buildings.” A neighbor who’s lived a mile away for 26 years says the company told her, flat out, this wouldn’t become a data center. When she brought them the SEC paperwork, she says they wouldn’t even say the words “data center” out loud, like it was a curse word instead of a filing.

That kind of two-faced messaging usually costs a company something. Here it might not cost SB Energy a thing, because the site was fully permitted before anyone downtown thought to write a rule against it. City Council passed an emergency resolution on Aug. 27 ordering staff to draft an actual data center zoning category. First update: December. Concrete’s already getting poured. You do that math.

A town hall runs on Thursday, Sept. 17, at Four Points Middle School if you’d like to ask SB Energy about water use, power draw, or the definition of the term “data center” in person.

The Housing Reform That Isn’t Reaching Who It Was Built For

Austin made it dramatically easier to build ADUs. The homeowners the policy was named for still can’t afford to use it.

Austin spent the last three years tearing down the zoning rules that kept small lots from holding more than one house, and it worked, in the sense that people are actually using it. HOME applications went from 24 in 2023 to north of 300 in each of the last two years. The city’s sitting on 1,108 of them now, and 45% are stacked in just two East Austin districts, the same districts where the city’s Black and Latino population has been shrinking for years.

A not-so-funny punch line of it all: the low-income homeowners this whole thing was supposedly built to protect can’t afford to use it. A backyard unit runs upward of $300,000 to build. The city studied whether it could finance that gap for years, hired consultants, ran the numbers with UT researchers, and landed on exactly the conclusion you’d guess if you’ve ever priced out a home addition: “an ADU financing program is unlikely to effectively serve low-income households.” Even a modest pilot loan fund would run the city $1.46 million just to open the doors.

125 Acres, Two Years, Still No Shovel in the Ground

The city bought a massive East Riverside site for $87 million in 2024. It’s still figuring out what to build.

The city bought 125 acres at Grove and Riverside for $87 million back in 2024, and in the two years since, the most concrete thing that’s happened on that land is a series of open houses. Three parcels, next to a light rail station that doesn’t exist yet, are still working through what the planning department calls “community visioning.” Council Member José Velásquez calls it a “once-in-a-generation opportunity.” Sure thing, José!

Meanwhile, a few blocks over, somebody who isn’t waiting on a consultant contract is already building the Grove Retail Center, 8,600 square feet of new retail at an estimated $860,000, right there on East Riverside Drive. A fraction of the scale of what the city owns next door, and it’ll be open and leasing storefronts long before Austin finishes deciding what color the ribbon should be.

Our Take

Austin’s government has gotten remarkably good at studying a problem and remarkably slow at building anything once the study’s done. The city has owned 125 acres at Grove and Riverside for two years and is still in the visioning phase. Meanwhile, a California energy company bought a shuttered 3M plant, filed the paperwork quietly, and started pouring concrete for a data center before the city even had a category to put it in. If you want something built in this town on any kind of timeline, don’t wait for City Hall to plan it for you. Buy the land, get your permits stacked before anyone notices what you’re actually building, and move. That’s not a compliment. It’s just how this city works right now.

What would your house sell for right now?

Not a Zestimate. Tell us about your place and we’ll send back a real number from people who know your neighborhood.

Get my home’s value

Global Real Estate Advisors · Rainey Property Group | Engel & Völkers

Want The Rainey Report in your inbox? Subscribe here.